Search
Banner ad

Guarding the Wrong Gate 

The views expressed in this article represent the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Chattanooga Area Chamber of Commerce, its staff, or its board of directors. 

In the spring of 2018, two Tennessee licensing boards met in Nashville three weeks apart. In March, Dr. Edward Owens asked the Board of Medical Examiners for his license back. The Memphis OBGYN had lost it after admitting he had sex with 11 patients and prescribed some of them large quantities of drugs without documentation, drugs he believed they were reselling. He had also come to work intoxicated and had twice lost hospital privileges. At the hearing, he wore a pressed suit, brought his lawyer and two psychiatrists, and apologized. One board member praised his “meticulous attention to recovery.” Another said, “I’m all about second chances.” The board gave him a new license. 

On April 9, across town, the Board of Cosmetology and Barber Examiners considered Omar Mahmoud. He was 52, an Arabic-speaking immigrant and a U.S. Army veteran of seven years in Iraq and Afghanistan. He had cut hair for more than 30 years, held a cosmetology license from Michigan, and had finished all the education Tennessee requires of barbers. What he could not do was pass Tennessee’s written exam on barbering theory, which is given only in English. Tennessee also refused to honor his Michigan license, because Michigan lets test-takers use interpreters. “I want to work,” he told the board. A member suggested he take the exam eight more times and then come back. The vote to deny him was unanimous. Put those two decisions side by side, and you can see how licensing in Tennessee works. It is hard on people trying to get in and easy on people who are already inside. 

A professional license is the state’s permission to do a job. Without it, doing the work is illegal, no matter how skilled you are or how willing a customer is to hire you. That makes a license different from a certification. A certification is someone vouching for you, and customers are free to hire you with it or without it. 

The permission is granted by licensing boards, roughly 2,000 of them across the country. Nearly all are made up mostly of part-time volunteers from the profession being regulated. Doctors oversee doctors, and barbers oversee barbers. These boards decide who may enter a profession and who must leave it, and between them they govern about one in five American workers, close to 30 million people. That is more than 10 times the number of workers covered by the federal minimum wage, and more than belong to public and private unions combined. 

Joshua Ammons is an Assistant Professor of Practice in Economics at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga 

The economic research on the entry side is extensive, and it points one way. Janna Johnson and Morris Kleiner, writing in the American Economic Journal, found that workers whose occupations require a state-specific licensing exam move between states 36 percent less often than other workers. When the exam is national, and a license earned in one state carries over to another, that gap essentially disappears. What keeps people like Omar Mahmoud from moving is each state writing its own test. 

Supporters of licensing say it protects quality, and that claim has been tested too. Chiara Farronato and her coauthors, in the American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, studied an online marketplace that showed customers whether each professional was licensed. The customers paid little attention to the license. They chose based on reviews and prices. States with stricter licensing had less competition and higher prices, and their customers were no more satisfied. Morris Kleiner and Evan Soltas, in the Review of Economic Studies, find that licensing raises pay for people inside a profession while reducing the number of jobs overall. 

None of this is new or partisan. Walter Gellhorn made the case in the University of Chicago Law Review in 1976, in an article titled “The Abuse of Occupational Licensing.” Economists have been documenting the costs of entry restrictions for 50 years. 

What economists have mostly missed is the second job these boards do, which is removing people who are dangerous. Rebecca Haw Allensworth, a law professor at Vanderbilt, spent four years attending Tennessee board meetings and reading their records. Her book, “The Licensing Racket,” published last year by Harvard University Press, reports what she found. 

Between 2016 and 2020, the Tennessee Board of Medical Examiners revoked a physician’s license in only 33 percent of the cases where it found sexual misconduct. Even a revoked doctor in Tennessee can normally reapply after a year. Fraud drew similar leniency. One physician who pleaded guilty to a federal felony in a $1.1 million healthcare fraud scheme received a reprimand. During years when 10,000 Tennesseans died of drug overdoses, the board kept nearly two-thirds of the doctors it found had prescribed improperly in practice. Allensworth could not find a single case in which the board permanently revoked a license for over-prescribing unless the doctor agreed to it. 

Dr. Michael LaPaglia, a Knoxville emergency physician, came before the board four times. He was arrested in 2014 for dealing opioids and other drugs out of his home. While on probation, he met another restricted doctor at a Narcotics Anonymous meeting the board had ordered him to attend. The two formed a clinic with no building, only a prescription pad, and LaPaglia sold prescriptions for $300 in cash, once in a McDonald’s parking lot. He pleaded guilty to two federal felonies. The board then restored his license with fewer restrictions than he had before. “I hope I’m a good judge of a heart,” one board member said. “I saw someone who has a good heart.” 

Tennessee is not unusual. Reporters at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution collected 2,400 board cases involving sexual misconduct with patients and found that boards kept half of those physicians in practice. Allensworth’s own summary is hard to improve on: “It may be hard to get into the club of the professionally licensed, but once you’re in, you’re in.” 

I discussed “The Licensing Racket” with my students at UTC. Many of them will work in licensed occupations, and all of them will hire people who do, so the book’s subject is their working lives and its evidence comes from their state. I am grateful to Allensworth for writing it, and for sitting through four years of board meetings so the rest of us can see what happens in them. 

I don’t share all of her conclusions, though. My own view is that almost all occupational licenses should be eliminated. If the state wants to make it illegal to work without its permission, the state should have to prove two things: that the risk to the public is real and imminent, and that the alternatives cannot handle it. Those alternatives already work across much of the economy. Underwriters Laboratories certifies that electrical products are safe, without a license for the companies that make them. Carfax tells buyers a used car’s history, without a license for the person selling it. And Farronato’s customers were already reading the reviews. 

Allensworth would keep more of the system. She wants far fewer licensed professions, but for those that remain, she wants full-time public regulators with training and data, instead of volunteer practitioners overseeing their own peers. 

That is a real disagreement about where the system should end up. It matters less than it sounds, because Tennessee is nowhere near either version. The choice actually in front of the state is whether to keep the current system, which fails in both directions, or to fix it in ways we would both support. She has watched volunteer boards protect dangerous providers, and I have watched them protect insiders from competition. The same reforms address both problems. 

The courts have already started down this road. In 2015, in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC, the Supreme Court ruled that a board controlled by members of the profession it regulates can be held liable under federal antitrust law for shutting out competitors, unless the state actively supervises it. In other words, a board run by insiders gets treated like a group of competitors, because that is what it is. 

The first reform is to honor licenses from other states. Johnson and Kleiner’s research shows that the barrier to moving comes from state-specific requirements rather than from licensing itself. Tennessee gains nothing by turning away a barber licensed in Michigan, and it lost a 30-year barber in April 2018. 

The second is to make the case for any new license before it passes. Whoever asks the legislature to license an occupation should have to show real harm to the public and explain why certification, disclosure, or ordinary lawsuits would not prevent it. Most such requests come from the profession that stands to benefit. 

The third is the reform Tennessee’s record most clearly calls for. Separate the job of admitting people to a profession from the job of disciplining them. The first job is done too strictly and the second too leniently, and a single board drawn from the profession has shown it will keep getting both wrong. Give the two jobs to different bodies, staffed differently. 

The costs of this system fall on people who were not in either hearing room. Dr. Owens had a lawyer and two psychiatrists. Dr. LaPaglia had a board member who judged his heart to be good. The patients those doctors would treat next had no one speaking for them, and neither did the customers who would never sit in Omar Mahmoud’s chair. 

We built these boards to protect the public and then handed them to the people they regulate. They have been guarding the wrong gate ever since.

Other Topics

Since 1993, P&C Construction has grown from one entrepreneur’s vision into a trusted Chattanooga contractor. As founder Royce Cornelison prepares for retirement, the company is building on a legacy of quality workmanship, strong relationships and community commitment.

Founded from a deeply personal experience, The Momentum Network helps student mothers overcome barriers through education, housing, childcare, and career development. By investing in moms and their children, the organization is helping build stronger families and a stronger Chattanooga.

New research from UTC's Center for Regional Economic Research shows that Chattanooga's small businesses remain a critical part of the local economy, but their role is changing. Here are three key findings business owners should understand and how they can help shape future research.

What started as a leap of faith from teaching to entrepreneurship has grown into one of the region's leading concrete coating companies. Chattanooga Floor Care combines craftsmanship, customer service, and continuous learning to deliver lasting value throughout the Chattanooga area.

This Chattanooga nonprofit is helping veterans, first responders, and the environment heal together through a unique mission.

For four decades, Cempa Community Care has evolved to meet the changing healthcare needs of our region. As the organization celebrates its 40th anniversary, it's also investing in the future with a major facility expansion designed to deliver more coordinated, patient-centered care for generations to come.

Sign up for weekly updates.

Guarding the Wrong Gate